PlainQuant

Is the US stock market in a bull or bear market?

Measured on the S&P 500 fund SPY.

Today

Bear Bear by the 150-day rule: SPY closed 4.6% below its 150-day average on 19 Nov 2026, below it since 16 Nov 2026.

The rule

Rule: hold SPY above its 150-day average, cash below.

Timing: checked at each close, traded at the next close.

Fund: the S&P 500 fund SPY, in US dollars.

Prices: dividends added back, so the gap to the line differs a little from a broker's chart.

Result over 5 years

19 Nov 2021 to 19 Nov 2026: +8.5% a year vs +10.3% for holding SPY; worst fall −18.3% vs −24.5%. That is less return and a smaller worst fall.

150-day rule Return a year+8.5% Worst fall−18.3%

3 Jan 2022 to 13 Mar 2023 · 78% in the market · 36 buys and sells

Holding SPY Return a year+10.3% Worst fall−24.5%

3 Jan 2022 to 12 Oct 2022 · 100% in the market · 0 buys and sells

Return since 19 Nov 2021 150-day ruleHolding SPY
-20%0%+20%+40%+60%2022Jul2023Jul2024Jul2025Jul2026Jul
-20%0%+20%+40%+60%20222023202420252026

Other lengths

In-sample: 150 days and the 5-year window were picked after trying 150–250 days on two windows.

AverageReturn a yearWorst fallDays in the marketBuys and sells
150 days ✓+8.5%−18.3%78%36
180 days+4.7%−29.0%78%42
200 days+5.2%−24.3%78%31
220 days+4.5%−26.2%79%35
250 days+4.3%−23.8%80%35
Holding SPY+10.3%−24.5%100%0

Year by year

Year150-day ruleHolding SPY
2021 · part of the year+1.6%+1.7%
2022−17.4%−18.2%
2023+19.4%+26.2%
2024+24.9%+24.9%
2025+17.0%+17.7%
2026 · part of the year+2.8%+5.8%

Bull vs bear days

Held: the fund on 78% of days (bull), cash on 22% (bear).

Bull days: volatility 13.2% a year, average +12.0% a year.

Bear days: volatility 27.4% a year, average +9.1% a year.

Bear days were rougher and averaged a lower return.

How it was tested

Series: SPY with dividends added back, in US dollars.

Timing: close vs its average; buy or sell at the next close, never the same one.

Costs: 0.06% a side (slippage and broker fees).

Cash: earns nothing.

Window: 19 Nov 2021 to 19 Nov 2026; every average warmed up on earlier prices.

Past only: What happened in the past, not a forecast.

FAQ

Is the US market in a bull or bear market now?

Bear by the 150-day rule: SPY closed 4.6% below its 150-day average on 19 Nov 2026, below it since 16 Nov 2026.

What is the 150-day rule?

Hold SPY while it closes above its 150-day average, cash while below. Checked at each close, traded at the next.

Did the 150-day rule do better than holding?

19 Nov 2021 to 19 Nov 2026: +8.5% a year vs +10.3% for holding SPY; worst fall −18.3% vs −24.5%. That is less return and a smaller worst fall.

Is the 200-day average better?

200-day: +5.2% a year, worst fall −24.3%. 150-day: +8.5%, −18.3%. Holding SPY: +10.3%, −24.5%.

Now run your first backtest

The rules' own signals on past and current prices, not advice for you.